Every recording—which I’ve listened to in its entirety, the only criterion for making it onto this list—is linked to its own page on castalbums.org (a site I highly recommend for serious collectors of theatre music).
An asterisk indicates a first-time listen.
1/5 – The Wiz [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
1/10 – Oliver! [The 2024 London Cast Recording]*
1/13 – Can-Can [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
1/13 – Damn Yankees [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
1/13 – New Girl in Town [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
1/13 – Redhead [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
1/13 – Sweet Charity [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
1/13 – Chicago [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
1/20 – Sister Act [2024 West End Cast Recording]*
1/22 – Robert and Elizabeth [Original London Cast Recording]
1/27 – Plain and Fancy [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
3/1 – I Can Get It For You Wholesale [New Cast Recording]*
3/28 – Once Upon a Mattress [The 2024 Broadway Cast Recording]*
4/18 – The Light in the Piazza [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
4/19 – Carousel [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
4/25 – Gypsy [2024 Broadway Cast Recording]*
5/5 – Damn Yankees [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
5/9 – Wonderful Town [1999 Studio Cast Recording]
5/15 – Legs Diamond [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
5/16 – Annie [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
5/22 – The 25th Annual Putnam County Spelling Bee [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
5/27 – Leave It to Me! [2001 San Francisco Cast Recording]*
5/30 – Next to Normal [Original London Cast Recording]*
5/31 – For Amusement Only [Original Australian Cast Recording]*
6/3 – Chicago [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
6/6 – Real Women Have Curves [Original Broadway Cast Recording]*
6/10 – Maybe Happy Ending [Original Broadway Cast Recording]*
6/13 – Floyd Collins [Original Cast Recording]
6/18 – The Crooked Mile [Original London Cast Recording]*
6/27 – Hello, Dolly! [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
6/29 – Real Women Have Curves [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
7/16 – The Curious Case of Benjamin Button [Original London Cast Recording]*
7/25 – A Chorus Line [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
7/29 – Show Boat [1993 World Premiere Cast Recording]
8/6 – Bells Are Ringing [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
8/15 – Floyd Collins [Original Broadway Cast Recording]*
8/22 – Dead Outlaw [Original Broadway Cast Recording]*
8/28 – 42nd Street [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
8/30 – By the Beautiful Sea [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
8/30 – My Fair Lady [2001 London Cast Recording]
9/1 – Allegro [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
9/6 – Kimberly Akimbo [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
9/10 – State Fair and the 20th Century Songbook [Studio Cast Recording]*
9/16 – Opening Night [Original London Cast Recording]*
9/22 – Natasha, Pierre & The Great Comet of 1812 [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
9/26 – My Fair Lady [World Premiere Complete Recording]*
10/1 – The Boy Friend [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
10/1 – My Fair Lady [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
10/1 – Camelot [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
10/3 – Follow That Girl [Original London Cast Recording]
10/3 – Little Mary Sunshine [Original London Cast Recording]
10/3 – Virtue in Danger [Original London Cast Recording]
10/3 – Darling of the Day [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
10/6 – Love Life [First Complete Recording]*
10/7 – The Sound of Music [Original London Cast Recording]
10/13 – Six [Studio Cast Recording]
10/15 – Kismet [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
10/16 – Mame [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
10/20 – Skyscraper [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
10/24 – Evita [2025 London Cast Highlights]*
10/24 – Pirates! The Penzance Musical [Original Broadway Cast Recording]*
11/6 – Passion Flower Hotel [Original London Cast Recording]
11/24 – Guys and Dolls [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
11/25 – Barbara Cook: It’s Better with a Band
11/30 – Pipe Dream [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
12/13 – Bye Bye Birdie [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
12/16 – The Bridges of Madison County [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
12/24 – She Loves Me [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
12/31 – Bye Bye Birdie [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
12/31 – Fanny [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
12/31 – Damn Yankees [Original Broadway Cast Recording]
12/31 – Little Mary Sunshine [Original London Cast Recording]